Measurement error

measurement system analysisAll measurements involve uncertainty. Suppliers of measuring equipment usually specify the measurement uncertainty as a symmetrical interval around the measurement result:

Measurement result ± measurement uncertainty

Example: The length of a special measuring rod is 2000 mm ± 1 mm. With a 95 % confidence interval, which is normal to use, there is a 95% probability that the rod is between 1999 mm and 2001 mm.

Measurement System Analysis (MSA), also referred to as Measurement System Evaluation (MSE), can determine the measurements accuracy, precision and stability. This is done by measuring the same item repeatedly. Based on the repeated measurements, the accuracy, precision and stability can be determined.

Measurements are done many different ways, using different kind of technologies.

Lean Tech has evaluated subjective measurement systems like appearance, taste and smell. Surprisingly, the measurement error for a visual test was greatest for the quality manager, who made the decision when there was doubt about the quality. The quality manager did not perform the test frequently, only occasionally when the quality was questioned. Ironically, this person's evaluation was less consistent than for operators whom performed the test more frequently.

Maybe you use cameras / automatic optical inspection (AOI) to control product quality? The measurement can be performed based on reference points identified by the camera. Measures of distance can be made between reference points to control product quality. Measurement System Evaluations performed by Lean Tech for camera controls, show that they are both accurate and precise if they find the right reference point. Unfortunately, they become unstable if they fail to find the correct reference point and thus render incorrect measurement. 

Here is a video about measurement error for a measurement you probably can relate to: weight. 

In this video, Components of variation (CoV) is used to decide measurement error and within day variation.

For manufacturing companies, it might be relevant to use CoV to decide how much variation is due to the measurement, different measuring instruments, different analyst or operator, and different batches.  This is important to know if you are making decisions based on measurements that are affected by several factors.

References

  • value stream mapping"I was very impressed with Sissel's Lean Six Sigma knowledge. She makes it easy to identify improvements and create results"
    - Daryl Powell, Lean Manager, Kongsberg Maritime SubseaValue stream mapping
  • Lean engineering"Sissel has worked as part of Cambis project team for two of our projects. Her main focus has been on process design, engineering and procurement. Sissel has proven herself as a competent and committed employee. She has been an important contributor to make good progress in the projects she has worked with. At the same time she is accurate and has good quality of the work she performs."
    - Eivind Willoch, Project Manager, Cambi AS lean engineering
  • benchmarking"We are very happy with the work carried out. We was not very clear what the order was, but with your background and expertise the outcome was what we were looking for and a document we will benefit from in the future"
    - Roger Søråsdekkan, Site Leader at Allnex, Norwaybenchmarking
  • monitoring program"We hired Lean Tech to develop monitoring program for air emission. The monitoring program should satisfy requirements from the Norwegian Environment Agency including sampling frequency to ensure representative samples, uncertainty estimates, calculations and preparation of reporting templates, etc. The assignment was delivered with the correct content at the right time. Recommended." monitoring program
    - Kjell Even Misfjord, SHE manager at Allnex, Norway  
  • monitoring program"Sissels ability to quickly understand the issue, as well as her commitment and expertise is impressive. Her analytical and thorough contribution to our monitoring program has been precise and targeted, and very educational. " monitoring program
    - Thomas Løvik, HSEQ advisor at TWMA, Norway